The recently created alliance between the Italian American One Voice Coalition (“IAOVC”) and the Native American Guardian’s Association (NAGA) marks an unprecedented milestone in the fight against what many perceive as the detrimental effects of cancel culture. This collaboration underscores the importance of preserving cultural heritage and ensuring that the narratives of various communities are respected and upheld.

Cancel culture, often defined as the practice of withdrawing support for public figures and companies after they have done or said something considered objectionable, has greatly expanded its reach to include the reevaluation and erasure of historical symbols, figures, and traditions. For Italian Americans and Native Americans, this phenomenon has led to the removal of culturally significant symbols and observances, such as Columbus Day and the names of sports teams like the Redskins.

Columbus Day is a critical point of pride for Italian Americans. For many Italian Americans, Columbus Day is not only a celebration of their heritage but also a recognition of their contributions to the development of the nation. Moreover, it is an atonement and apology for the discrimination and denigration experienced by generations past, most pointedly, the 1891 lynching of 11 innocent Italian Americans in New Orleans and other lynchings during that period.  The movement to replace Columbus Day with Indigenous Peoples' Day has been seen by some as an attempt to erase this significant part of their cultural identity. While it is essential to acknowledge and respect the history and suffering of Native Americans, many Italian Americans feel that the outright cancellation of Columbus Day negates their heritage and contributions.  Through this new alliance, NAGA agrees that Columbus Day should not be eliminated.

Similarly, Native Americans have faced the removal or renaming of symbols and mascots that have been part of the American lexicon and sports culture for decades. One of the most notable examples is the change of the Washington Redskins' name. For many Native Americans, the name "Redskins" and other similar symbols are not derogatory terms but foster a sense of pride and recognition. The removal of these symbols, often decided without comprehensive consultation with the greater Native American population, is perceived as an erasure of their presence and influence in American history and society.  And, IAOVC supports NAGA in the pursuit of maintaining these culturally important symbols of Native Americans.

The alliance between IAOVC and NAGA is significant for several reasons. First, it brings together two communities that have historically had limited interaction, fostering a sense of unity and mutual support. By joining forces, these groups can amplify their voices, making it clear that cultural heritage and identity are not issues to be handled unilaterally by external forces but require the input and agreement of the communities involved.

Second, this alliance highlights the importance of dialogue and understanding. Both organizations recognize the need to educate the broader public about the significance of their cultural symbols and the reasons they should be preserved.

Lastly, this partnership sets a precedent for other cultural and ethnic groups facing similar challenges. It demonstrates that unity and collaboration can be powerful tools in advocating for the preservation of cultural identity in the face of a growing trend towards cancel culture. By working together, marginalized communities can ensure their voices are heard and their histories are honored.

The alliance between the Italian American One Voice Coalition and the Native American Guardians Association is a crucial development in the ongoing debate over cancel culture. It emphasizes the importance of preserving cultural heritage, promotes dialogue and understanding, and sets an example for other groups facing similar challenges. This collaboration is not just about opposing cancel culture but about advocating for a more inclusive and respectful approach to cultural representation and history.  All are invited to participate in the monthly online meetings with NAGA and IAOVC – The Solidarity Sessions – “Bridging Cultures Against Cancel Culture.”  Visit www.thesolidaritysessions.com to register for the next online meeting.

In addition to Native Americans and Italian Americans, NAGA is inviting other groups to join this important alliance against cancel culture.  Visit nagaeducation.org/general-9-1 and join the Seven Generations Alliance.